Forum |  HardWare.fr | News | Articles | PC | S'identifier | S'inscrire | Shop Recherche
2973 connectés 

 
 


 Mot :   Pseudo :  
 
 Page :   1  2
Page Suivante
Page Précédente
Bas de page 
Auteur Sujet :

MP3 @320 Vs FLAC pour sono de qualité

n°1945601
PinkFloyd3​1
Jancoviciste
Posté le 16-11-2014 à 19:00:49  profilanswer
 

Reprise du message précédent :
merci, çà me rassure.
 
je commençais à avoir peur.  :lol:  :jap:


---------------
Le plus dur c'est pas l’Atterrissage, c'est la Chute. «Dieu se rit des hommes qui déplorent les effets dont ils chérissent les causes» FAFO.
mood
Publicité
Posté le 16-11-2014 à 19:00:49  profilanswer
 

n°1945602
Profil sup​primé
Posté le 16-11-2014 à 19:05:39  answer
 

Elias de Kelliwich a écrit :


 
Il y'a même des FLAC qui sont des ré-encodage de MP3...  [:cosmoschtroumpf]  
 
C'est bien pour ça, qu'il faut prendre le CD d'origine et l'encoder soit même pour faire un vrai test, sinon ça fausse tout...  ;)
 
CD d'origine > Rip > WAV 44100 / 16 Bits
 
WAV > Flac
 
WAV > MP3 320kbps
 
WAV > MP3 192kbps
 
WAV > MP3 128kbps
 
Ensuite on peut faire un vrai test ABX avec les différents fichiers.  :hello:


 
J'avais un soft il y a un bail qui pouvait dire si le flac était original ou pas  :D  
Bon, je vais le chercher...
Hop, je crois que c'était ça :
http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/audio [...] sic-files/
 :hello:  

n°1945604
PinkFloyd3​1
Jancoviciste
Posté le 16-11-2014 à 19:09:02  profilanswer
 

merci pour le soft, je vais tester çà sur le 16bits....
j'ai un léger doute. :)

 

edit : ah beh non.


Message édité par PinkFloyd31 le 16-11-2014 à 19:13:23

---------------
Le plus dur c'est pas l’Atterrissage, c'est la Chute. «Dieu se rit des hommes qui déplorent les effets dont ils chérissent les causes» FAFO.
n°1945771
PinkFloyd3​1
Jancoviciste
Posté le 17-11-2014 à 21:11:07  profilanswer
 

lol
 
il est génial ce logiciel.
 
j'avais un doute sur des FLAC, ce coup-ci par contre......
 

Citation :

AUDIOCHECKER v2.0 beta (build 457) - by Dester - opdester@freemail.hu
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 
Started at: lundi, 17. 11. 2014. - 20:53.57
28 files found
 
01 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\01. Somewhere in Between - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
02 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\02. Love Doctor - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
03 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\03. Dark Angel - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
04 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\04. Gunfire in a Juke Joint - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
05 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\05. My Time Is Numbered - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
06 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\06. Alligator Ass - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
07 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\07. BBQ - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
08 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\08. Hoochie Koochie Man - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
09 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\09. Talk to My Ass - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
10 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\10. Dust My Broom - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
11 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\11. Slow Boat to China - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 98%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
12 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\12. She Dat Pretty - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
13 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\13. Red Rooster - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
14 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\14. Shake - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 99%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
15 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\01. Girl It's Alright - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
16 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\02. Don't You Cry - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
17 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\03. Music - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
18 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\04. Better Man - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
19 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\05. Route 23 - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
20 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\06. My God - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
21 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\07. Lollipop - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
22 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\08. Not for Sale - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
23 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\09. Dance - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
24 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\10. Jealousy - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
25 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\11. War - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
26 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\12. Strut - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
27 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\13. Goree - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
28 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\14. The Light - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
 
Finished at: lundi, 17. 11. 2014. - 20:58.53 (operation time: 0:04.55)
 
-----------------------------------------------------------
 
Started at: lundi, 17. 11. 2014. - 21:05.09
28 files found
 
01 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\01. Somewhere in Between - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
02 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\02. Love Doctor - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
03 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\03. Dark Angel - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
04 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\04. Gunfire in a Juke Joint - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
05 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\05. My Time Is Numbered - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
06 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\06. Alligator Ass - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
07 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\07. BBQ - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
08 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\08. Hoochie Koochie Man - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
09 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\09. Talk to My Ass - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
10 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\10. Dust My Broom - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
11 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\11. Slow Boat to China - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 98%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
12 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\12. She Dat Pretty - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
13 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\13. Red Rooster - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
14 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Mojo Priest\14. Shake - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 99%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
15 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\01. Girl It's Alright - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
16 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\02. Don't You Cry - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
17 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\03. Music - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
18 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\04. Better Man - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 100%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
19 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\05. Route 23 - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
20 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\06. My God - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
21 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\07. Lollipop - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
22 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\08. Not for Sale - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
23 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\09. Dance - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
24 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\10. Jealousy - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
25 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\11. War - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
26 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\12. Strut - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
27 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\13. Goree - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
28 -===- C:\Users\Floyd\Music\Steven Seagal - 2-CD-2010\Steven Seagal - Songs From The Crystal Cave\14. The Light - Steven Seagal.flac
  Extracted successfully
  Conclusion: this track is MPEG with probability 95%
  Tempfile successfully deleted.
 
 
Finished at: lundi, 17. 11. 2014. - 21:09.44 (operation time: 0:04.35)


 
 :D

Message cité 1 fois

---------------
Le plus dur c'est pas l’Atterrissage, c'est la Chute. «Dieu se rit des hommes qui déplorent les effets dont ils chérissent les causes» FAFO.
n°1945776
Profil sup​primé
Posté le 17-11-2014 à 22:16:37  answer
 

Donc tu regarde de la musique :/ :o

n°1945777
PinkFloyd3​1
Jancoviciste
Posté le 17-11-2014 à 22:19:31  profilanswer
 

j'ai pas compris.  [:spamafote]


---------------
Le plus dur c'est pas l’Atterrissage, c'est la Chute. «Dieu se rit des hommes qui déplorent les effets dont ils chérissent les causes» FAFO.
n°1945782
Profil sup​primé
Posté le 17-11-2014 à 22:56:17  answer
 

mpeg c'est aussi pour de la vidéo ;) :D

n°1945785
PinkFloyd3​1
Jancoviciste
Posté le 17-11-2014 à 23:20:37  profilanswer
 

ah oui, mais pour moi, çà voulait dire MP3.
j'ai même pas tilté. :)


---------------
Le plus dur c'est pas l’Atterrissage, c'est la Chute. «Dieu se rit des hommes qui déplorent les effets dont ils chérissent les causes» FAFO.
n°1945791
BoraBora
Dilettante
Posté le 18-11-2014 à 00:07:48  profilanswer
 

PinkFloyd31 a écrit :

lol
 
il est génial ce logiciel.
 
j'avais un doute sur des FLAC, ce coup-ci par contre......


T'emballe pas trop quand même.  ;) Tous ces softs pour vérification de fichiers issus de sites douteux ont leurs limites, assez vite atteintes. Qui plus est, ça ne t'indique en rien que le CD a été correctement rippé (si tant est que ce soit bien un CD). Et encore moins si le mastering est correct. Or il vaut mieux un MP3 bien encodé d'un bon mastering qu'un FLAC d'un mastering médiocre.


---------------
Qui peut le moins peut le moins.
n°1947345
feyris
Posté le 26-11-2014 à 22:22:21  profilanswer
 

La dernière fois, j'ai passé toute la collection de flac d'un collègue avec un programme du genre (probablement celui la), j'avais genre 50% de vrai flac.
A moins de ripper soi même, je vois pas d'alternative.
Il n'y a pas de base de donnée de crc de rip ?

Message cité 1 fois
mood
Publicité
Posté le 26-11-2014 à 22:22:21  profilanswer
 

n°1947369
BoraBora
Dilettante
Posté le 27-11-2014 à 01:53:14  profilanswer
 

feyris a écrit :

La dernière fois, j'ai passé toute la collection de flac d'un collègue avec un programme du genre (probablement celui la), j'avais genre 50% de vrai flac.
A moins de ripper soi même, je vois pas d'alternative.
Il n'y a pas de base de donnée de crc de rip ?


Si, celle d'AccurateRip (très fiable) et celle de CueTools (beaucoup plus douteuse, pour le coup).


---------------
Qui peut le moins peut le moins.
mood
Publicité
Posté le   profilanswer
 

 Page :   1  2
Page Suivante
Page Précédente
Haut de page 

Aller à :
Ajouter une réponse
 

Sujets relatifs
Câblage de qualité Denon-FocalComment prendre la meilleure qualité audio d'une musique sur internet
Le bluetooth haute qualité APT-XGros pixel carré violet, mauvaise qualité ?
Qualité des câbles YUVRéencodage flac en mp3
Qualité sonore du Sony TA AX-44 ? Réparer ou remplacer ?[MP3] Quel MP3 choisir ?
[Test] Qualité d'un TV 39" à moins de 300€ 
Plus de sujets relatifs à : MP3 @320 Vs FLAC pour sono de qualité

Forum MesDiscussions.Net, Version 2010.2
(c) 2000-2011 Doctissimo
Page générée en 0.059 secondes

Copyright © 1997-2025 Groupe LDLC (Signaler un contenu illicite / Données personnelles)