![http://up.sur-la-toile.com/i8hX http://up.sur-la-toile.com/i8hX](http://up.sur-la-toile.com/i8hX)
Ami RPGiste bonjour !
Face à l'hérésie du classement rpg de nos amis de jvc, nous nous devons de réagir et rétablir la vérité aux yeux du monde...
enfin notre vérité...
donc La Vérité !
ce topic n'a pas pour but de remplacer l'irremplaçable topic rpg où la question de zelda reviendra sans cesse mais simplement de voter suivant le thème abordé (jrpg, rpg occidentaux, oldies, rpg console, rpg PC, le top 10 - la crême de la crême...)
Pour répondre, merci d'utiliser ce canevas ![:o :o](https://forum-images.hardware.fr/icones/redface.gif)
Citation :
Classement ultime RPG 1- 2- 3- 4- 5- 6- 7- 8- 9- 10-
|
1 à 5 points seront distribués aux jeux cités
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT RPG Officiel HFR
1- Final Fantasy VII ...................................................122 pts 2- Final Fanatsy VI .....................................................93 pts 3- Baldur's gate ........................................................83 pts 4- Chrono trigger .......................................................68 pts 5- Baldur's gate 2 ......................................................65 pts 6- Secret of mana .......................................................55 pts 7- Mass effect ..........................................................54 pts 8- Mass effect 2 ........................................................38 pts 9- Chrono Cross .........................................................33 pts 10- Deus Ex .............................................................30 pts 11- Star Wars : kotor ...................................................29 pts 11- Ultima 7 ............................................................29 pts 13- Vagrant Story .......................................................28 pts 14- Final Fantasy X .....................................................27 pts 15- Final Fantasy IX ....................................................23 pts 16- Lands of Lore .......................................................23 pts 17- Dragon Age ..........................................................21 pts 17- Suikoden 2 ..........................................................21 pts 19- Fallout .............................................................20 pts 19- Morrowind ...........................................................20 pts 19- Skyrim ..............................................................20 pts 19- Xenoblade ...........................................................20 pts 19- Xenogears ...........................................................20 pts 24- Dragon Quest VIII ...................................................19 pts 25- Planescape Torment ..................................................18 pts 25- Skies of arcadia ....................................................18 pts 25- The Legend of Zelda : A Link to the Past ............................18 pts 25- Valkyria profile ....................................................18 pts 29- Dark Souls ..........................................................16 pts 29- Might & Magic World of Xeen (MM4 + MM5) .............................16 pts 29- Suikoden ............................................................16 pts 32- Fallout 3 ...........................................................15 pts 33- Fallout 2 ...........................................................14 pts 34- Demon Souls .........................................................13 pts 34- Deus Ex : Human revolution ..........................................13 pts 35- Final Fantasy IV ....................................................12 pts 35- Lost Odyssey ........................................................12 pts 37- Fallout New Vegas ...................................................10 pts 39- Eye of the beholder 2 ................................................9 pts 39- System Shock .........................................................9 pts 39- Tengai makyou 2 ......................................................9 pts 39- The Legend of Zelda : Ocarina of Time ................................9 pts 39- Ultima Underworld 2 ..................................................9 pts 44- Ultima World .........................................................8 pts 45- Arcanum ..............................................................7 pts 45- Castlevania Symphony of The Night ...................................7 pts 45- Eye of the beholder ..................................................7 pts 45- Final Fantasy XIII ...................................................7 pts 45- Panzer Dragoon Saga ..................................................7 pts 45- Persona 4 ............................................................7 pts 45- Tengai makyou 4 ......................................................7 pts 45- Valkyria chronicles ..................................................7 pts 53- Grandia ..............................................................6 pts 53- Persona 3 ............................................................6 pts 53- The Legend of Zelda : Link's Awakening ...............................6 pts 56- Fire enblem ..........................................................5 pts 56- Phantasy star III ....................................................5 pts 56- Shadow hearts covenant ...............................................5 pts 56- System Shock 2 .......................................................5 pts 56- The Witcher ..........................................................5 pts 61- Earthbound ...........................................................4 pts 61- Final Fantasy VIII ...................................................4 pts 61- Final Fantasy tactics ................................................4 pts 61- Golden Sun ...........................................................4 pts 61- Phantasy Star ........................................................4 pts 61- Phantasy star IV .....................................................4 pts 61- The Legend of Zelda ..................................................4 pts 68- Dark cloud 2 .........................................................3 pts 68- Oblivion .............................................................3 pts 68- Radiant historia .....................................................3 pts 68- Secret of evermore ...................................................3 pts 68- Shining Force III ....................................................3 pts 68- Ys 1 & 2 .............................................................3 pts 74- Gothic 2 .............................................................2 pts 74- Nier .................................................................2 pts 74- Star Wars : kotor 2 ..................................................2 pts 74- Terranigma ...........................................................2 pts 74- The bard's tale ......................................................2 pts 74- Ys 4 .................................................................2 pts 80- Diablo ...............................................................1 pt 80- Rings of Zilfin ......................................................1 pt 80- Shining in the darkness ..............................................1 pt 80- Suikoden 3 ...........................................................1 pt 80- Vampire Bloodlines ...................................................1 pt 80- Wild arms ............................................................1 pt
|
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT RPG Occidentaux
1- Baldur's Gate ..........................................................59 pts 2- Mass Effect 1 ..........................................................55 pts 3- Baldur's Gate 2 ........................................................50 pts -- Skyrim .................................................................50 pts 5- The Witcher ............................................................36 pts 6- Planescape .............................................................32 pts 7- Fallout 2 ..............................................................31 pts 8- Dragon Age Origins .....................................................29 pts 9- Ultima 7 ...............................................................27 pts 10- Morrowind .............................................................23 pts 11- Mass Effect 2 .........................................................16 pts 12- Arcanum ...............................................................15 pts 13- Lands of Lore .........................................................13 pts 14- Fallout ...............................................................12 pts 15- Demon's Souls .........................................................11 pts 16- Dungeon master ........................................................10 pts 17- Dark Souls .............................................................9 pts -- Might & Magic 6 .........................................................9 pts -- Oblivion ................................................................9 pts 20- Star Wars : KOTOR ......................................................9 pts 21- Deus Ex 3 ..............................................................7 pts -- The Witcher 2 ...........................................................7 pts 23- Arx Fatalis ............................................................6 pts -- Vampire : the masquerade - Bloodlines ...................................6 pts 25- Alpha protocol .........................................................5 pts -- Daggerfall ..............................................................5 pts -- Neverwinter Nights 2 ....................................................5 pts 28- Deus Ex ................................................................4 pts -- Divinity 2 ..............................................................4 pts -- Fallout New Vegas .......................................................4 pts -- Might & Magic 4 .........................................................4 pts -- Neverwinter Nights 1 ....................................................4 pts -- Ultima underworld 2 .....................................................4 pts -- Wizardry 8 ..............................................................4 pts -- Fallout 3 ...............................................................4 pts -- Heroes of M&M 4 .........................................................4 pts 36- Darklands ..............................................................3 pts -- Eye of the beholder .....................................................3 pts -- Gothic 2 ................................................................3 pts -- Heroes of M&M ...........................................................3 pts -- Might & Magic 7 .........................................................3 pts -- Might & Magic World of Xeen .............................................3 pts -- Titan Quest .............................................................3 pts -- Ultima Underworld .......................................................3 pts -- Dragon Age 2 ............................................................3 pts 44- Diablo 2 ...............................................................2 pts -- Eye of the beholder 2 ...................................................2 pts -- Gothic 3 ................................................................2 pts -- Icewind Dale ............................................................2 pts -- System Shock 2 ..........................................................2 pts -- Ultima 6 ................................................................2 pts 50- Anachronox .............................................................1 pts -- Dofus ...................................................................1 pts -- Wizardry 1 ..............................................................1 pts -- World of warcraft .......................................................1 pts
|
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT jRPG
![http://www.partitioncollection.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/FF7.jpg http://www.partitioncollection.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/FF7.jpg](http://www.partitioncollection.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/FF7.jpg)
1- Final Fantasy 7 .......................................................100 pts 2- Final Fantasy 6 ........................................................60 pts 3- Secret of mana .........................................................45 pts 4- Final Fantasy 10 .......................................................44 pts 5- Lost Odyssey ...........................................................31 pts 6- Chrono Trigger .........................................................28 pts 7- Skies of arcadia .......................................................23 pts 8- Final Fantasy 8 ........................................................20 pts -- Persona 4 ..............................................................20 pts 10- Vagrant Story .........................................................19 pts 11- Final Fantasy 9 .......................................................18 pts --- Shadow hearts 2 .......................................................18 pts 12- Xenogears .............................................................16 pts 13- Chrono Cross ..........................................................14 pts -- Xenoblade ..............................................................14 pts 15- Zelda : Ocarina of Time ...............................................13 pts 17- Final Fantasy 12 ......................................................12 pts 18- Persona 3 .............................................................11 pts -- Suikoden 2 .............................................................11 pts 20- Suikoden ..............................................................10 pts --- Baten Kaidos ..........................................................10 pts 22- Final Fantasy 13 .......................................................9 pts 23- Grandia II .............................................................8 pts 24- Valkyrie Profile .......................................................7 pts -- Tales of Symphonia ......................................................7 pts 25- Dragon Quest 8 .........................................................6 pts -- Dragon Quest 9 ..........................................................6 pts -- Secret of Evermore ......................................................6 pts 28- Eternal Sonata .........................................................5 pts -- Golden Sun ..............................................................5 pts -- Grandia .................................................................5 pts -- Legend of dragoon .......................................................5 pts -- Okami ...................................................................5 pts -- Shining Force 3 scenario 3 ..............................................5 pts 34- Dragon Quest 5 .........................................................4 pts -- Phantasy Star 2 .........................................................4 pts -- Tengai Makyou : Daishi no Mokushiroku The Apocalypse IV .................4 pts -- Xenosaga ................................................................4 pts -- Zelda : Link's Awakening ................................................4 pts 40- Arc the lad 2 ..........................................................3 pts -- Odin Sphere .............................................................3 pts -- Phantasy Star 4 .........................................................3 pts -- Shenmue .................................................................3 pts -- Tales of Phantasia ......................................................3 pts 45- Breath of fire 3 .......................................................2 pts -- Legend of mana ..........................................................2 pts -- Radiant Historia ........................................................2 pts -- The Story of Thor .......................................................2 pts -- The Story of Thor .......................................................2 pts -- Wild Arms ...............................................................2 pts 50- Final Fantasy 4 ........................................................1 pts -- Lunar ...................................................................1 pts -- Nier ....................................................................1 pts -- Pokemon Rouge ...........................................................1 pts -- Sakura Taisen 3 .........................................................1 pts -- Star ocean 2 ............................................................1 pts -- Star ocean 4 ............................................................1 pts -- Tales of Eternia ........................................................1 pts -- Valkyria Chronicles .....................................................1 pts
|
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT RPG CONSOLE
1- Final Fantasy 7 ......................................................27 pts 2- Final Fantasy 6 ......................................................20 pts 3- Persona 4 ............................................................12 pts 4- Lost Odyssey ..........................................................9 pts 5- Chrono Trigger ........................................................8 pts - Chrono Cross ..........................................................8 pts - Demon's Souls ..........................................................8 pts - Dragon Quest 8 .........................................................8 pts 9- Dark Souls ............................................................7 pts - Final Fantasy 9 ........................................................7 pts 11- Final Fantasy 12 .....................................................6 pts 12- Mass Effect ..........................................................5 pts - Skyrim .................................................................5 pts - Suikoden 2 .............................................................5 pts - Xenogears ..............................................................5 pts - Zelda : a link to the past .............................................5 pts 17- Vagrant story ........................................................4 pts 18- Dragon Age : Origins .................................................3 pts - Nocturne ...............................................................3 pts - Story of Thor ..........................................................3 pts - Zelda : Ocarina of time ................................................3 pts 22- Deus Ex : HR .........................................................2 pts - Final Fantasy 10 .......................................................2 pts - Persona 3 ..............................................................2 pts - Secret of mana .........................................................2 pts 26- Dragon Quest 9 .......................................................1 pts - Panzer Dragoon Saga ....................................................1 pts - Radiant Historia .......................................................1 pts - Skies of Arcadia .......................................................1 pts - Tales of abyss .........................................................1 pts |
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT RPG PC
![http://media1.gameinformer.com/imagefeed/featured/classicgi/baldursgate2/bg2_box.jpg http://media1.gameinformer.com/imagefeed/featured/classicgi/baldursgate2/bg2_box.jpg](http://media1.gameinformer.com/imagefeed/featured/classicgi/baldursgate2/bg2_box.jpg)
1- Baldur's gate 2 ......................................................25 pts 2- Baldur's Gate ........................................................14 pts - The witcher ...........................................................14 pts 4- Dragon Age : Origins .................................................13 pts 5- Mass Effect 1 ........................................................11 pts - Lands of lore .........................................................11 pts 7- Nerverwinter Nights ...................................................9 pts 8- Arcanum ...............................................................7 pts - SW : KOTOR .............................................................7 pts 10- Deus Ex ..............................................................5 pts - Might & Magic 6 ........................................................5 pts - Planetscape torment ....................................................5 pts - Ultima 7 ...............................................................5 pts 14- Diablo 2 .............................................................4 pts - Fallout 3 ..............................................................4 pts - Might & Magic 4 ........................................................4 pts - Oblivion ...............................................................4 pts - The witcher 2 ..........................................................4 pts 19- Alpha Protocol .......................................................3 pts - Fallout ..............................................................3 pts - Ultima World ...........................................................3 pts 22- Skyrim ...............................................................2 pts 23- Eye of the beholder 2 ................................................1 pts - Fable ..................................................................1 pts - Jade empire ............................................................1 pts - Might & Magic 7 ........................................................1 pts - Vampire the masquerade : Bloodline .....................................1 pts |
___________________________________________________________________
CLASSEMENT OLDIES
![http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRn7MrWGN-Y5btdL5nsnsJE12Jy2rl1Ohb2EosGpQIRQXwJyIfBXFe9nHxbDQ http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRn7MrWGN-Y5btdL5nsnsJE12Jy2rl1Ohb2EosGpQIRQXwJyIfBXFe9nHxbDQ](http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRn7MrWGN-Y5btdL5nsnsJE12Jy2rl1Ohb2EosGpQIRQXwJyIfBXFe9nHxbDQ)
1- Final Fantasy 6 ......................................................47 pts 2- Chrono Trigger .......................................................28 pts 3- Eye of the beholder ..................................................23 pts 4- Zelda a link to the past .............................................21 pts 5- Lands of Lore ........................................................20 pts 6- Vagrant story ........................................................15 pts 7- Secret of mana .......................................................12 pts 8- Zelda link'awakening .................................................12 pts 9- Final fantasy 4 ......................................................11 pts 10- Dungeon Master ......................................................10 pts - Final Fantasy 7 .......................................................10 pts - Ultima 9 ..............................................................10 pts 13- Phantasy Star 4 ......................................................9 pts - The Bard's Tale ........................................................9 pts 15- Alternate Reality ....................................................8 pts - Baldur's gate ..........................................................8 pts - Diablo 2 ...............................................................8 pts - Eye of the beholder 2 ..................................................8 pts - Ultima 8 ...............................................................8 pts 20- Baldur's gate 2 ......................................................7 pts - Dragon Quest 4 .........................................................7 pts - Ishar ..................................................................7 pts - Ravenloft : Straad'sPossession .........................................7 pts - Wizardry ...............................................................7 pts 26- Daggerfall ...........................................................6 pts - Dragon Quest 5 .........................................................6 pts - Fallout ................................................................6 pts - Rings of Zilfin ........................................................6 pts 30- Autoduel .............................................................5 pts - Legend of Thor .........................................................5 pts - Mystic Quest ...........................................................5 pts - Phantasy Star ..........................................................5 pts - Pokemon Red 1 Blue .....................................................5 pts 35- Final Fantasy Tactics ................................................4 pts - Phantasy 2 .............................................................4 pts 37- Final Fantasy 3 ......................................................3 pts - Landstalker ............................................................3 pts - Suikoden 2 .............................................................3 pts 40- Shining force 2 ......................................................2 pts - Terranigma .............................................................2 pts 42- Might & Magic 6 ......................................................1 pts - Xenogears ..............................................................1 pts |
---------------
Achat/Vente PS3, Vita - "T'es mort 3 fois, t'es un noob, man !" - "0,07"